What’s Wrong with the headline “Judge Blocks Trump’s Plan to Bar Immigrants Who Can’t Pay for Health Care

The court ruling is the latest to derail administration initiatives to limit the admission of certain legal immigrants into the United States.

President Trump’s proclamation barred immigrants who could not prove they had health insurance or the ability to pay for medical costs once they became permanent residents of the United States.
A federal judge on Saturday blocked the Trump administration from implementing a policy that would require immigrants to prove they have insurance or the financial resources for medical costs in order to obtain a visa.

The ruling, by Judge Michael Simon of the Federal District Court in Portland, Ore., was the latest in a string of court decisions to derail administration initiatives that would limit the admission of certain legal immigrants into the United States.

Judge Simon issued a nationwide temporary restraining order preventing the government from carrying out a proclamation by President Trump that would have gone into effect on Sunday.

Mr. Trump’s Oct. 4 proclamation ordered consular officers to bar immigrants who could not prove they had health insurance or the ability to pay for medical costs once they become permanent residents of the United States.

The president had justified the policy on the grounds that immigrants were more likely to be uninsured, and that “costs associated with this care are passed on to the American people in the form of higher taxes, higher premiums, and higher fees for medical services,” the measure said.

Legal immigrants are three times as likely as American citizens to be uninsured, according to a Kaiser Family Foundation study.

Lawyers from Justice Action Center, Innovation Law Lab and the American Immigration Lawyers Association argued that the policy was “plainly illegal” and that it would cause immediate and irreparable harm.

“This new requirement rewrites our immigration and health care laws,” the lawyers wrote in a motion seeking a temporary restraining order. They noted that the policy could effectively bar up to 375,000 “otherwise qualified immigrants each year.”

An official at the White House could not be immediately reached for comment. The Department of Justice, through a spokesman, declined to comment on the ruling.

Commentary: So how many of you Americans want to pay for Immigrants health care costs? We should have Judge Michael Simon pay for it!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.